Markets
BTC$60,192+1.69%ETH$1,680+3.39%SOL$70.13+0.98%XRP$0.9276+1.31%BNB$548.25+1.20%DOGE$0.0551+1.14%ADA$0.1444+0.49%TRX$0.3055+1.03%LINK$8.58+0.06%AVAX$6.57−0.32%SUI$0.6451−1.60%HYPE$61.26−0.55%
USD · 24h
Saturday, November 21, 2026Crypto markets, policy & blockchain
Digital Coin Journal
Regulation

Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV Case

A federal judge acquitted the Peraire-Bueno brothers in the $25M Ethereum MEV case after finding no proven material misrepresentation.

Courtroom scene with a judge's gavel atop a legal brief bearing the Ethereum logo, signaling an MEV ruling.

A federal judge in Manhattan has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of all charges arising from a $25 million Ethereum MEV operation that prosecutors said unfolded in roughly 12 seconds. In a November 16 46-page opinion and order, U.S. District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke concluded that prosecutors failed to establish the material misrepresentation required to support wire fraud. The ruling ends the first-of-its-kind prosecution without declaring MEV exploitation broadly lawful.

The brothers had been charged with conspiracy to commit wire fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering over an April 2023 strategy known as Omakase. Prosecutors alleged they exploited a vulnerability in MEV-Boost infrastructure to reveal transaction bundles submitted by sandwich-trading bots and replace transactions in a way that generated approximately $25 million. The court accepted that the strategy disrupted the bots and generated substantial profits, but found that those facts did not supply the missing fraud element.

Court Rejects Three Fraud Theories

The government’s case ultimately centered on three alleged forms of deception: the lure transactions used to attract sandwich bots, a so-called false signature submitted through the relay process and the brothers’ failure to behave according to the intended design of MEV-Boost. Clarke found that none of the three amounted to a material misrepresentation on the trial evidence.

The lure transactions were particularly important to the court’s rejection of the government’s spoofing analogy. In traditional spoofing cases, traders place orders they intend to cancel in order to create a false appearance of supply or demand. Here, the lure transactions were actually executed and added to Ethereum rather than withdrawn. The court also found no implicit promise that placing those transactions meant they had to be bundled or executed in the manner the sandwich traders expected.

Clarke separately examined the allegedly false blockheader signature. The Peraire-Buenos had entered incorrect state and parent root values, but the Ultrasound Relay did not check those fields before revealing the underlying transactions. Because the relay would have released the data regardless of what values appeared in those fields, the alleged falsity did not affect the recipient’s behavior and therefore was not material.

The ruling also rejected the idea that violating the intended operation or “spirit” of MEV-Boost could independently establish fraud. Testimony showed that validators interacting with the system did not agree to terms of use, while its specifications described software behavior rather than enforceable rules governing participants. Ethereum itself was described in the opinion as a “trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use.”

Ruling Draws a Narrow Boundary Around MEV Enforcement

The judgment follows a nearly four-week trial in 2025 that ended when jurors could not reach a unanimous verdict. Clarke subsequently considered the brothers’ Rule 29 motion for judgment of acquittal and determined that no reasonable jury could sustain the charged fraud theories on the evidence presented. The money-laundering conspiracy count also fell because it depended on wire fraud as the underlying unlawful activity.

That technical distinction matters in a DeFi environment where MEV can produce substantial economic losses without necessarily fitting conventional fraud frameworks. An earlier AAVE trade that suffered extreme slippage and MEV extraction illustrated how transaction ordering can redistribute value without requiring a compromise of Ethereum itself. Networks are also experimenting with technical defenses, including Aptos’ encrypted mempool designed to reduce frontrunning and sandwich attacks. The Peraire-Bueno decision addresses the criminal-law boundary around one MEV strategy, not whether MEV presents an economic or technical risk.

The ruling is also materially different from crypto enforcement actions built around more conventional allegations of customer-asset misuse or financial misconduct, including the Alex Mashinsky settlement and personal penalties. Here, the central question was whether interaction with permissionless software communicated a legally actionable falsehood. Clarke’s answer was limited to this record and these charges: frustrating another participant’s expectations or a protocol’s intended design was insufficient without proof of a material misrepresentation.

The clerk was directed to close the case following the judgment of acquittal. The decision therefore ends the prosecution against the Peraire-Bueno brothers while leaving broader questions about how other statutes, regulatory regimes or future cases might treat MEV strategies unresolved.

Travis Bennett

Hello! Let me introduce myself: I'm Travis Bennett, a Policy Analyst and Web3 Reporter based in Scotland. My main job is to navigate the maze of global crypto regulation. For years, I have been analyzing how laws and government decisions shape the future of this industry, always with a critical eye.

More from Travis Bennett →

This article is for information only and is not investment advice. We report under our Editorial Policy; to flag an error, see our Corrections Policy.